Climate movement wins lawsuit against Heerlen municipality: ‘the right to demonstrate is a great thing’

Bekijk alles
September 8, 2023
News items
Previous
Next

On Sept. 6, 2023, the Limburg District Court ruled that 3 of the 6 restrictions on the 2021 Klimaatalarm demonstration in Heerlen were unlawful. This is good news for the right to demonstrate.

The case was brought by Klimaatcoalitie Parkstad and 6 national organizations of the Climate Crisis Coalition, including: Environmental Defense, Greenpeace, Code Red, Grandparents for Climate, DeGoedeZaak and Extinction Rebellion.

The Climate Alert took place on March 14, 2021, during the peak of the corona pandemic. Demonstrators wore mouth masks and kept the 1.5-meter distance. Yet the Heerlen municipality imposed several restrictions on them. Against 6 of these restrictions the organizers of the demonstration appealed to the municipality and then to the court, on 3 of these issues Klimaatcoalitie Parkstad was vindicated by the court.

The court found that the rule that the number of participants in the demonstration may not exceed 200 was permissible, but ruled that the obligation to send people away when this maximum was reached was wrongly imposed, since this is not a task of the organization of this demonstration, but of the public authority.

Nor should the obligation to provide names of speakers in a timely manner have been imposed. By doing so, the municipality is interfering with the content of the thoughts and feelings of the demonstrators. This violates the right to demonstrate.

Finally, the obligation that deals with not obstructing traffic also cannot stand, since some traffic disruption must be tolerated during a demonstration. It is up to the government to ensure that traffic is managed.

Lotte Keularts of Klimaatcoalitie Parkstad: “Good that the judge recognized that many of the restrictions went too far. Organizing the demonstration was not made easy for us, while the climate crisis is disrupting our world. Just look at the floods in southern Limburg.’

The coalition’s lawyer, Jelle Klaas of PILP, calls the ruling a win for the right to demonstrate in the Netherlands. According to experts, this is under pressure: ‘It is the task of municipalities to facilitate demonstrations. Restrictions may only be imposed if they are necessary and in line with the law and human rights. That was not the case here. The court outlined some clear new boundaries for restrictions. This is good news for future demonstrations.’

Read more about the right to protest on our file page. The full ruling can be accessed here.

Tags: , ,
Previous
Next
Actueel

Gerelateerde berichten

climate climate change
May 28, 2026 Climate change

Two climate activists from Heerlen take their case to the UN Human Rights Committee over restrictions on peaceful protest

Today, two climate activists from Heerlen have launched a case against the Netherlands at the UN Human Rights Committee. The case concerns restrictions imposed by the municipality of Heerlen in March 2021 on a peaceful demonstration against the climate crisis. Following the Dutch court’s decision to uphold a number of significant restrictions, the organisers of […]

Islamophobia Mosque
February 11, 2026 Islamophobia en surveillance

Dutch Data Protection Authority Fines 10 Municipalities for Illegally Processing Information on Muslims

The Dutch Data Protection Authority (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, AP) has imposed fines totaling €250,000 on ten municipalities. The reason is that they processed files containing sensitive information about Islamic residents without the residents’ knowledge. In doing so, the municipalities violated the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). They were not authorized to possess this information. The municipalities […]

Delft Islamophobia Mosque
February 11, 2026 Islamophobia en surveillance

Delft Council apologises to Al-Ansaar Mosque

PILP has assisted the Al Ansaar mosque in recent years in legal proceedings concerning a secret investigation commissioned by the Municipality of Delft and carried out by the research and consultancy firm Nuance door Training en Advies (NTA). On 12 February 2025, the District Court of The Hague ruled that the Municipality of Delft had […]

1 2 3 35 36 37
Gerelateerde berichten

Our Dossiers

Our Dossiers

Support our work

PILP is the legal ally of civil society organizations, movements, communities, and activists dedicated to human rights. Your donation enables us to continue providing this service.