Ethnic profiling – Royal Military Police

Ethnic profiling – Royal Military Police

A coalition of civil organizations and citizens has summoned the Royal Marechaussee (KMar) to put an end to discriminatory border controls. On February 14, 2023, the Court of Appeal ruled that the KMar’s practices constitute a form of racial discrimination and prohibited them. Lawyers from PILP and Houthoff represented the coalition.

Ethnic Profiling by the Marechaussee

During border controls, marechaussees selected individuals based on their appearance, skin color, or origin (ethnicity). Additionally, the Royal Marechaussee utilized risk profiles that included ethnicity, such as men who walk quickly, are well-dressed, and appear “non-Dutch.” This form of discrimination is in violation of human rights and Dutch law and is therefore prohibited.

Ethnic profiling has a negative impact. It harms the individuals affected, contributes to the stigmatization of ethnic minorities, undermines trust in the government, and proves ineffective in combating crime.

The collaborating organizations and citizens have repeatedly highlighted the harmful effects of ethnic profiling to the government. International human rights bodies have also urged the Netherlands for years to fulfill its duty to protect citizens against discrimination and prevent ethnic profiling. Despite all this, there were no significant improvements.

Legal Action to Stop Discrimination

Despite criticism and recommendations, the government insisted that ethnicity, in combination with other characteristics, may be part of general risk profiles and can be used in selection decisions. This allowed the Royal Marechaussee to discriminate against citizens, with the knowledge of the Second Chamber (Tweede Kamer), which did not intervene. Hence, the coalition felt compelled to take the matter to court.

The coalition initiated a civil procedure against the state, arguing that the Royal Marechaussee should not use ethnicity in selection decisions and the creation of risk profiles. Legally speaking, developing and using risk profiles that include ethnicity for border controls violate the prohibition of discrimination.

As plaintiffs in this case, the following entities acted:

Acting as plaintiffs in this case are:

The coalition is represented by lawyers from PILP and Houthoff.

Appeal Court Ruling

Following an unfavorable ruling by the lower court, the Court of Appeal in The Hague ruled on February 14, 2023, that the current practices of the KMar constitute a form of racial discrimination and prohibited them. This was a groundbreaking decision. The Dutch State decided not to appeal to the Supreme Court against the Court of Appeal’s ruling on ethnic profiling by the Royal Marechaussee. The State accepts the ruling of the Court of Appeal, making it final.

Report Discrimination by the Marechaussee

If you believe you were subjected to a check or discriminatory treatment by a Royal Marechaussee officer based on your origin or skin color, share your experiences with an anti-discrimination bureau. Complaint handlers are available to listen and provide support throughout the complaint procedure.

In een oogopslag

Startdatum:
26 februari 2020
Partners:

Amnesty International
Control Alt Delete
Anti-discrimination agency RADAR
Dutch Lawyers Committee for Human Rights
Two "non-white" citizens repeatedly ethnically profiled by the Royal Military Police.

Huidige status:

On February 14, 2023, the Court of Appeal ruled that the current practices of the Royal Marechaussee (KMar) constitute a form of racial discrimination and prohibited these practices. The Dutch State will not appeal to the Supreme Court against the decision of the Court of Appeal in The Hague regarding ethnic profiling by KMar.

Gerelateerde Documenten

Gerelateerde berichten

Met de tag: Ethnic profiling – Royal Military Police
ethnic profiling verdict
February 13, 2024 Ethnic profiling

Ethnic profiling: the current situation in 2024

In February 2024, our clients sent a letter to the cabinet urging them to formally declare in writing that ethnic profiling is prohibited and to enforce this ban across all government organizations. This call comes a year after the Court of Appeal in The Hague affirmed that ethnic profiling constitutes discrimination and is therefore illegal. […]

ethnic profiling lawsuit
February 16, 2023 Ethnic profiling

State Police ruling final: Cabinet, take effective action now against ethnic profiling

The Dutch State will not appeal the decision of the Court of Appeal of The Hague on ethnic profiling by the Royal Netherlands Marechaussee (KMar). The State is resigning itself to the court’s ruling, making it final. This is an important step in the fight against racism and discrimination. The lawsuit was filed by a […]

appeal ethnic profiling lawsuit
February 15, 2023 Ethnic profiling

Court prohibits ethnic profiling

This morning the Court of Appeal issued a landmark ruling in the case of two citizens, Amnesty International, Control Alt Delete, RADAR and NJCM against the state over ethnic profiling by the Royal Military Police (KMar). Lawyers from PILP and Houthoff assisted the coalition in these proceedings. The court ruled that the KMar’s current method […]

1 2 3 4
Gerelateerde berichten

Our Dossiers

Our Dossiers

Support our work

PILP is the legal ally of civil society organizations, movements, communities, and activists dedicated to human rights. Your donation enables us to continue providing this service.