Appeal of demonstration law Hague won

Bekijk alles
May 8, 2017
News items
Previous
Next

In an important case on the right to demonstrate, the State Council upheld the appeal.

The case involved a 2017 announced demonstration in The Hague by citizens who wanted to organize a short symbolic hunger strike in front of the Moroccan embassy. This in solidarity with Moroccan human rights activists.

The organizers of the action received an email message from the police informing them that the mayor could not allow the form, place and time of the demonstration. Among other things, it was indicated that a hunger strike could be perceived as shocking by bystanders. Therefore, the demonstration was not allowed to proceed as planned.

The organizers decided to cancel the demonstration and appealed the demonstration ban. They invoked their right to demonstrate in front of the embassy, choosing the form of the demonstration. The mayor of The Hague refused to consider the objection to the demonstration ban because the mayor felt that the police email would not be a decision. About that, one of the organizers litigated first in court and then in the Council of State.

The court and the State Council weighed in on whether the police email was sent on behalf of the mayor and whether the email was a prohibition against demonstrating or, as the municipality argued, an invitation to consult.

The court rejected the appeal.

The court’s ruling was appealed. Because allowing mayors to ban demonstrations (through the police) by e-mail without the possibility of objection is not only a curtailment of the right to demonstrate but also a restriction of access to justice.

The State Council, in its ruling of Oct. 9, 2019, fortunately overturned the court’s ruling and thus the views of the municipality (read the ruling here).

According to the Council of State, the e-mail from the police showed: “concretely and unambiguously that the mayor has decided that the demonstration could not take place in the manner desired by the organization. The e-mail is thus aimed at legal effect, namely prohibiting the reported demonstration.”

This means that mayors cannot simply prohibit demonstrations (via the police) by e-mail, without the possibility of objection by demonstrators.

All parties involved are very pleased with this beautiful and clear ruling by the Council of State.

Now that the Council of State has deemed the e-mail to be a decision, the demonstration organizers can move on to the substance of the objection: on whether the mayor was allowed to ban the demonstration. PILP views this procedure with confidence.

The organizers of the demonstration were supported and assisted in this lawsuit by PILP and by attorney Alexander IJkelenstam of law firm CMS (through Pro Bono Connect).

Tags: , , ,
Previous
Next
Actueel

Gerelateerde berichten

climate climate change
May 28, 2026 Climate change

Two climate activists from Heerlen take their case to the UN Human Rights Committee over restrictions on peaceful protest

Today, two climate activists from Heerlen have launched a case against the Netherlands at the UN Human Rights Committee. The case concerns restrictions imposed by the municipality of Heerlen in March 2021 on a peaceful demonstration against the climate crisis. Following the Dutch court’s decision to uphold a number of significant restrictions, the organisers of […]

Islamophobia Mosque
February 11, 2026 Islamophobia en surveillance

Dutch Data Protection Authority Fines 10 Municipalities for Illegally Processing Information on Muslims

The Dutch Data Protection Authority (Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens, AP) has imposed fines totaling €250,000 on ten municipalities. The reason is that they processed files containing sensitive information about Islamic residents without the residents’ knowledge. In doing so, the municipalities violated the General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). They were not authorized to possess this information. The municipalities […]

Delft Islamophobia Mosque
February 11, 2026 Islamophobia en surveillance

Delft Council apologises to Al-Ansaar Mosque

PILP has assisted the Al Ansaar mosque in recent years in legal proceedings concerning a secret investigation commissioned by the Municipality of Delft and carried out by the research and consultancy firm Nuance door Training en Advies (NTA). On 12 February 2025, the District Court of The Hague ruled that the Municipality of Delft had […]

1 2 3 35 36 37
Gerelateerde berichten

Our Dossiers

Our Dossiers

Support our work

PILP is the legal ally of civil society organizations, movements, communities, and activists dedicated to human rights. Your donation enables us to continue providing this service.