Ruling in lawsuit: unions not admissible, but judge urges short-term clarity

Bekijk alles
March 9, 2023
News items
Previous
Next

In a summary judgment ruling today, the preliminary relief judge ruled that unions FNV and CNV are inadmissible in the lawsuit against the State to enforce financial relief for care workers with Long Covid. PILP is acting as attorney for union FNV in the case. The unions had sued the State in summary proceedings in a collective action. An advance payment of damages was sought for all healthcare workers who suffered Long Covid in 2020. The preliminary injunction judge now says that such a collective action is not possible in these summary proceedings.

According to the interim relief judge, the circumstances under which different care workers had to perform their jobs are too different to pass judgment on them in these summary proceedings. This means that the judge in preliminary relief proceedings will not rule on the substance of the case, and therefore will not answer the question of whether the State is liable for the damage incurred by care employees. For this reason, the interim relief judge also does not express an opinion on the question of whether it is right for the State to want to make a settlement for a limited group, namely only the healthcare workers who were infected between March and June 2020.

However, the interim relief judge does say that it is understandable that the unions started these proceedings.

‘In all reasonableness, it cannot be disputed that those affected have a strong interest in obtaining clarity in the short term about compensation for the financial consequences related to their efforts in the health care sector in the first period after the corona pandemic reached the Netherlands and the infections contracted as a result, which led to long-term illness. However understandable it is that the trade unions have seized on these summary proceedings as a crowbar, this legal route cannot offer solace on the grounds mentioned above.’

PILP will consult with union FNV about the ruling of the preliminary injunction court and possible follow-up steps.

Read more about this case here.

Tags: , , ,
Previous
Next
Actueel

Gerelateerde berichten

Liberties network report Rule of law
March 17, 2025

Democracy in Decline: Liberties’ Rule of Law Report 2025 Exposes Serious Concerns

The 2025 Rule of Law Report by the Civil Liberties Union for Europe (‘Liberties‘) that was published today, reveals a concerning picture: democratic institutions in the EU continued to weaken in 2024 due to government neglect or active dismantling. The report, compiled by 43 human rights organisations—including PILP as a member of Liberties—provides a critical […]

demonstratierecht Sint Maarten
March 14, 2025 Right to protest

New case won in Sint Maarten: Minister lifts conditions on peaceful protest

The Minister of Justice of Sint Maarten has decided that the conditions that were imposed on the demonstration of January 10, are in violation of the law and human rights and had to be withdrawn. SXM in Solidarity with Palestine has been vindicated by the Justice Minister of Sint Maarten, Nathalie Tackling on all points. […]

demonstratierecht
March 4, 2025 Right to protest

New report on security measures at universities: What are the limits of what universities can do? 

PILP has recently published a new report on the increasing security measures being implemented at Dutch universities. Over the past year, various media outlets have reported on (new) far-reaching measures being used by several Dutch universities. There have been reports of, for example, the use of plainclothes security personnel, the (covert) checking of bags, asking […]

Gerelateerde berichten

Our Dossiers

Our Dossiers

Support our work

PILP is the legal ally of civil society organizations, movements, communities, and activists dedicated to human rights. Your donation enables us to continue providing this service.