Research on ethnic profiling in the Netherlands, England and Wales

Bekijk alles
May 12, 2017
News items
Previous
Next

Utrecht University was commissioned by PILP to conduct research on ethnic profiling in the Netherlands, England and Wales. The study was conducted by Simone Vromen and is entitled: Ethnic profiling in the Netherlands and England and Wales: Compliance with international and European standards.

Vromen concludes in her study that the broad discretionary power of police officers in the Netherlands, England and Wales can lead to ethnic profiling and thus violate the prohibition of discrimination. As early as 2010, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) warned of the risk of ethnic profiling under the British Terrorism Act 2000. The effectiveness of ethnic profiling to combat crime has never been demonstrated and it is unlikely that the proportionality principle of the ECHR can be met in such practices.

Unlike in the Netherlands, precautions have been taken in England and Wales to prevent and deal with ethnic profiling. By collecting quantitative data and introducing further guidelines for police officers, England and Wales are now acting in line with recommendations given by various international and European human rights organizations. Vromen recommends that the Netherlands also take such precautions in its policy to meet international and European standards.

In her research, Vromen draws on international and European human rights standards applicable in the context of ethnic profiling. She discusses, among other things, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the application of the European Social Charter, the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights. In doing so, Vromen also analyzed ECHR case law regarding the prohibition of discrimination.

The research can be accessed here.

Tags: ,
Previous
Next
Actueel

Gerelateerde berichten

analyse report research residence permit right to protest students
September 2, 2024 Right to protest

Analysis: Consequences of participating in protests for residence permits of students and staff

Everyone has the right to protest. International students and employees at educational institutions in the Netherlands also have this right, regardless of their residence status. PILP has received many questions about whether and how participation in a demonstration can affect the residence permits of international students and employees at educational institutions. In this analysis, PILP […]

bezwaar climate change demonstratierecht
July 30, 2024 Right to protest

Climate activists Twente object to restrictions on their right to demonstrate in Hengelo

Four climate activists affiliated with Extinction Rebellion Twente planned to demonstrate in Hengelo on May 25, 2024. The demonstration was supposed to have been a small demonstration on the climate crisis, calling on the public to participate in follow-up actions and activities around climate justice. The mayor of Hengelo imposed as many as 10 restrictions […]

Human Rights Board verdict
July 25, 2024 Discrimination by banks

Verdict: ING discriminates against customers based on their ethnicity in transaction checks

The National Institute on Human Rigths (NIHR) ruled on 25 July 2024 that ING discriminated in checks for terrorist financing. The bank wrongfully froze customers’ accounts and asked them extra questions about transactions solely because of their surname or the inclusion of a so-called “non-Dutch-sounding” name in the description. This particularly greatly affected people of […]

Gerelateerde berichten

Our Dossiers

Our Dossiers

Support our work

PILP is the legal ally of civil society organizations, movements, communities, and activists dedicated to human rights. Your donation enables us to continue providing this service.