Right to protest – Sint Maarten

Right to protest – Sint Maarten

The inhuman and horrific events in Israel and Gaza have led people around the world to organise demonstrations and marches calling for a ceasefire and in solidarity with the plight of Palestinians.

A group of concerned citizens in St Maarten also felt compelled to take to the streets and organise a dignified and peaceful demonstration in solidarity with those suffering in Palestine.

During consultations, in which police and organisers responded positively to each other, a march route was determined and a date agreed for 19 November 2023.

However, the Justice Minister banned the march with a formal decision on 17 November 2023. The minister, using the term propaganda, stated that there were rumours on the internet regarding the protest, which allegedly involved destruction of property and a call to burn flags. The authorities said they expected serious unrest that could not be prevented by imposing restrictions on the demonstration: the only option left was to ban it completely, effectively resulting in a ban on the associated freedom of expression and assembly.

The organisers decided to take legal action and an appeal was sent to the Court of First Instance last December. PILP is working with lawyer Brenda Brooks of Brooks & Associates on this case. A date for the hearing is currently being awaited.

In een oogopslag

Startdatum:
17 november 2023
Partners:

Residents of St Maarten.
Lawyer Brenda Brooks of Brooks & Associates.

Huidige status:

On November 25, 2024, the Court of First Instance ruled: the ban on the demonstration in Sint Maarten was unjustified.

Gerelateerde Documenten

Rechtzaak Right to protest – Sint Maarten

21 December 2023

Appeal filed

PILP files appeal on behalf of demonstration organisers.

Appeal filed

19 November 2023

Supposed date demonstration

Supposed date demonstration

The demonstration in solidarity with the Palestinians should have taken place on 19 November 2023.
17 November 2023

Minister bans demonstration

Minister bans demonstration

The Minister of Justice bans the demonstration through a formal decree.
10 November 2023

Demonstration announcement

Demonstration announcement

The organisers announce the demonstration for 19 November 2023.
On November 25, 2024

the Court of First Instance ruled: the ban on the demonstration in Sint Maarten was unjustified.

Historic victory in Sint Maarten: the first court case affirms the right to protest and strengthens freedom of speech and peaceful assembly

the Court of First Instance ruled: the ban on the demonstration in Sint Maarten was unjustified.

Tijdlijn

Gerelateerde berichten

Met de tag: Right to protest – Sint Maarten
analyse report research residence permit right to protest students
September 2, 2024 Right to protest

Analysis: Consequences of participating in protests for residence permits of students and staff

Everyone has the right to protest. International students and employees at educational institutions in the Netherlands also have this right, regardless of their residence status. PILP has received many questions about whether and how participation in a demonstration can affect the residence permits of international students and employees at educational institutions. In this analysis, PILP […]

bezwaar climate change demonstratierecht
July 30, 2024 Right to protest

Climate activists Twente object to restrictions on their right to demonstrate in Hengelo

Four climate activists affiliated with Extinction Rebellion Twente planned to demonstrate in Hengelo on May 25, 2024. The demonstration was supposed to have been a small demonstration on the climate crisis, calling on the public to participate in follow-up actions and activities around climate justice. The mayor of Hengelo imposed as many as 10 restrictions […]

bezwaar complaint demonstratierecht protest verdict
July 12, 2024 Right to protest

KOZP and NLWB win objection case over Slochteren demonstration

Kick Out Zwarte Piet (KOZP) and Stichting Nederland Wordt Beter (NLWB) peacefully demonstrated on November 25, 2023 in Slochteren against the discriminatory parts of the Sinterklaas parade there. The mayor of Midden-Groningen had imposed several restrictions on this demonstration. The mayor had done so for fear of disorder. KOZP and NLWB found this fear unjustified […]

1 2 3 4 5
Gerelateerde berichten

Our Dossiers

Our Dossiers

Support our work

PILP is the legal ally of civil society organizations, movements, communities, and activists dedicated to human rights. Your donation enables us to continue providing this service.