Documents on arms export license released after PILP appeal

Bekijk alles
October 6, 2022
News items
Previous
Next

Since 2020, PILP has been litigating against the Minister of Foreign Trade and Development Cooperation (BHOS) over the right to access information on arms exports for Egypt. No document was provided by BHOS because of the customs authorities’ duty of confidentiality. The court upheld the appeal. Some of the requested documents must now be released.

A Wob request by PILP about an arms export license to Egypt was rejected by BHOS. This is because, according to the minister, these documents are subject to customs secrecy. PILP was not allowed to see any of the documents, even after the objection procedure. In 2021, PILP appealed this decision.

According to the Minister for BHOS, it is “evident” that some documents, such as permit applications, are covered by Customs’ duty of confidentiality, because these documents contain information provided confidentially to Customs. Other documents, such as internal memos, also fall under the duty of secrecy, according to the minister. This last category of documents, according to PILP, cannot in any case fall within the scope of the duty of secrecy. Moreover, by not releasing anything at all, the minister is violating Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR), according to PILP.

On October 6, 2022, the Amsterdam District Court issued its ruling. The court ruled that some of the requested documents should be disclosed. The disclosure of these documents was not to be refused on grounds of confidentiality, nor on other grounds.

PILP sees a worrisome trend in the handling of information requests that are (partly) related to customs. In fact, other NGOs are also dealing with requests that are denied because the requested information would fall under the professional secrecy of customs.

Public access to government information is of great importance for the proper functioning of our democratic constitutional state. In a controversial issue like arms exports, where human rights are at stake, transparency is all the more important. NGOs, such as PILP and our allies, fulfill the role of “public watchdog” in this, according to the European Court of Human Rights. Without access to information, NGOs cannot properly fulfill this monitoring role.

PILP is currently in discussion with partners about the possibility of an appeal.

Read the ruling of the Amsterdam Court here.

Previous
Next
Actueel

Gerelateerde berichten

report research residence permit right to protest students
September 2, 2024 Right to protest

Analysis: Consequences of participating in protests for residence permits of students and staff

Everyone has the right to protest. International students and employees at educational institutions in the Netherlands also have this right, regardless of their residence status. PILP has received many questions about whether and how participation in a demonstration can affect the residence permits of international students and employees at educational institutions. In this analysis, PILP […]

bezwaar climate change demonstratierecht
July 30, 2024 Right to protest

Climate activists Twente object to restrictions on their right to demonstrate in Hengelo

Four climate activists affiliated with Extinction Rebellion Twente planned to demonstrate in Hengelo on May 25, 2024. The demonstration was supposed to have been a small demonstration on the climate crisis, calling on the public to participate in follow-up actions and activities around climate justice. The mayor of Hengelo imposed as many as 10 restrictions […]

Human Rights Board verdict
July 25, 2024 Discrimination by banks

Verdict: ING discriminates against customers based on their ethnicity in transaction checks

The National Institute on Human Rigths (NIHR) ruled on 25 July 2024 that ING discriminated in checks for terrorist financing. The bank wrongfully froze customers’ accounts and asked them extra questions about transactions solely because of their surname or the inclusion of a so-called “non-Dutch-sounding” name in the description. This particularly greatly affected people of […]

Gerelateerde berichten

Our Dossiers

Our Dossiers

Support our work

PILP is the legal ally of civil society organizations, movements, communities, and activists dedicated to human rights. Your donation enables us to continue providing this service.