Right to housing – WOZ cap

Right to housing – WOZ cap

Case on “WOZ-cap” – right to property versus right to housing

In October 2023, the Dutch State was sued by the foundation Fair Huur voor Verhuurders (“Fair Huur”, meaning “fair rent”). Fair Huur is an interest group for private landlords. PILP is  representing the Woonbond in this case, an interest group for tenants and house seekers. The Woonbond has joined the proceedings between Fair Huur and the State as a third party.

The WOZ cap

In these proceedings, Fair Rent focuses on the so-called “WOZ cap.” The WOZ-cap is an instrument of rent protection, aimed at somewhat curbing excessive rents in the free sector and hence making rental housing in the Netherlands more affordable. It ensures that the WOZ value (i.e.: property value) is less decisive in determining the maximum rent for a housing unit.

To calculate the maximum rent, a point system is used in the Netherlands. The WOZ value of a property affects the number of points that is assigned to a property: the higher the WOZ value, the more points. The number of points determines whether a property falls within the free sector or the regulated sector. With the WOZ value rising sharply in many places over the recent years, maximum rental prices also rose, making rental housing increasingly less affordable. To counteract this development, the Dutch legislature has instituted, among other things, the WOZ cap.

Fair Huur Foundation

Fair Huur has sued the State in a class action lawsuit. Fair Rent argues that the WOZ-cap infringes the property rights of private homeowners, thus violating Article 1 of the First Protocol to the ECHR (the right to the protection of property). In addition, the WOZ-cap would allegedly violate the prohibition of discrimination, because housing corporations would not be equally affected by the measure as private landlords. Fair Huur firstly claims that the WOZ-cap should be declared non-binding.

The Woonbond

The Woonbond acts as an advocate for tenants and house seekers, and is committed to affordable rents and good housing in liveable neighbourhoods. The Woonbond does not agree with Fair Huur’s contentions. Therefore, the Woonbond has asked the court to join the State in this lawsuit. The court has granted the joinder of the Woonbond. The Woonbond is therefore acting as a third party in these proceedings.

Right to housing as a fundamental human right

The Woonbond argues in these proceedings that the right to housing is a fundamental human right as enshrined in, inter alia, article 22 of the Dutch Constitution. Granting Fair Huur’s claims would be a step backwards in the realization of the right to housing. In addition, according to the Woonbond, the WOZ-cap is a measure that serves the public interest, which should prevail over the interests of private landlords.

In een oogopslag

Startdatum:
October 2023
Partners:

Fair Huur
Woonbond

Huidige status:

Current status: on December 2nd, 2024, a hearing will take place at the The Hague Court of First Instance. During this hearing, the Woonbond will defend the interests of tenants and house seekers. The hearing is open to the public.

Gerelateerde Documenten

Rechtzaak Right to housing – WOZ cap

2 December 2024

Hearing

Current status: on December 2nd, 2024, a hearing will take place at the The Hague Court of First Instance. During this hearing, the Woonbond will defend the interests of tenants and house seekers. The hearing is open to the public.

Hearing

6 May 2024

Statement of Defence

On May 6th, 2024, the Woonbond filed a statement of defence, in which the Woonbond defends the interests of tenants and house seekers and underlines that the WOZ cap is in the public interest.

Statement of Defence

27 March 2024

Merger Woonbond allowed

On March 27th, 2024, the Woonbond was admitted as a joined party in the proceedings between Fair Huur and the State.

Merger Woonbond allowed

13 February 2024

Conclusion to merge Woonbond

On February 13th, 2024, the Woonbond filed a statement for joinder, in which the Woonbond asked the court to be admitted as a party to the proceedings.

Conclusion to merge Woonbond

October 2023

Summons

In October 2023, Fair Huur sued the State for alleged unlawfulness of the WOZ-cap in respect of private landlords.

Summons

Tijdlijn

Gerelateerde berichten

Met de tag: Right to housing – WOZ cap
right to housing Woonbond
May 17, 2024 The right to housing

Dutch ‘Woonbond’ responds in lawsuit over excessive rents

The Woonbond is a Dutch organisation, standing up for the rights and interests of tenants in the Netherlands.  In March 2024, the Woonbond, supported by lawyers from PILP, joined a lawsuit filed by private landlords against the Dutch State. These landlords, united in the Fair Rent for Landlords Foundation (hereinafter ‘Fair Rent’), sued the State […]

intervention lawsuit Woonbond
March 27, 2024 The right to housing

Woonbond admitted in lawsuit over excessive rents due to WOZ value

The Woonbond (‘Tenant Union’) intervenes in the lawsuit of landlords against the State regarding the “WOZ-cap”. Today, the court in The Hague has ruled that the Woonbond’s intervention in this case is allowed. The court determines that tenants and prospective home seekers in the Netherlands will experience consequences of rising rental prices if the WOZ-cap […]

migration Ombudsman right to housing
February 2, 2023 The right to housing

MiGreat and Breakthrough file complaint with Ombudsman: ‘Taking tents away from people in need outrageous’

February 2, 2023. MiGreat and Doorbraak, supported by lawyers from PILP, filed a complaint with the National Ombudsman about the taking away of tents from people who had no other form of shelter and were forced to sleep outside at the application center in Ter Apel. Late summer 2022, hundreds of people, who wanted and […]

1 2
Gerelateerde berichten

Our Dossiers

Our Dossiers

Support our work

PILP is the legal ally of civil society organizations, movements, communities, and activists dedicated to human rights. Your donation enables us to continue providing this service.